I have been using the solid deoderant for about a week now and am very happy with its performance. My armpits do not smell at the end of each day. My 16yr old daughter is also using and has not complained. 5***** for natural ingrediants 5***** for product packaging being 100% zerowaste 5***** for parcel packaging being 99.9% zerowaste 3*** for price Do think both the solid deo sticks and tinned deodorant is very pricey at 7 odd pounds per item and it does niggle me that those trying to be earth conscious...especially zerowasters have to pay through the nose for products and this could force people back to the cheaper plastic versions.