After searching for a decent deodorant that is "earth conscious" and wors, I found this site. I bought the stick, bar and cream. The stick is fabulous. The cardboard casing doesn't give up and it smells lovely. I got the unscented bar, and I bought a tin to put it in. Both the stick and bar apply without pulling the skin. The cream does solidify but with a little rub becomes pliable. I would buy all of them again, no complaints. In truth I am likely to stick to the deodorant stick because its very handy to put in gym bag, work bag etc. So far they all seem to do the job.